BUSH, GEORGE W.   Term Paper ID:30185 Click to get this paper

Essay Subject: Examines the President's effective leadership during the crisis created by terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.... More...

9 Pages / 2025 Words 16 sources, 26 Citations, MLA Format $36.00 Return to List of Papers

Paper Abstract: Examines the President's effective leadership during the crisis created by terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. View of President's leadership abilities before and after 9/11. Contends that prior to 9/11, Bush did not appear to be an above average President, but after 9/11, he displayed strong leadership capacity. Paper Introduction: GEORGE W. BUSH AS PRESIDENTIAL LEADER This research paper examines the capacity and skills of President George W. Bush (Bush) for leading the United States effectively during the crisis created by the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in New York and the Pentagon in Washington and related threats. Prior to the occurrence of the events of September 11, 2001, the extent of Bush's Presidential leadership potential was very much in doubt owing in large part to the public perception of him created during the recent presidential electoral campaign, the post-election dispute and Bush's performance during his first eight months in office. After a somewhat shaky start, Bush responded well to the crisis of September 11 and displayed many of the skills and characteristics of an effective President in dealing with the threat of Text of the Paper: The entire text of the paper is shown below. However, the text is somewhat scrambled. We want to give you as much information as we possibly can about our papers and essays, but we cannot give them away for free. In the text below you will find that while disordered, many of the phrases are essentially intact. From this text you will be able to get a solid sense of the writing style, the concepts addressed, and the sources used in the research paper. Nixon said "as he grows accustomed toseeing large consequences from making his own decisions, the leader growsmore comfortable making those decisions and more ready to risk the resultsof his own errors" (328). Nixon in his book Leaders said"virtually all great leaders . He facesvery severe challenges to his limited but growing capacity and skills as apresidential leader. Will he be more successful in sustaining publicconfidence for a long, protracted and often frustrating war which may notalways go well or will he succumb to public impatience and turn hisattention elsewhere? "Bush Faces the Greatest Test." New York Times, 17 Sept. Will the public lose patience with his leadership anddeny him a second term? . It said he was "a different man" "more confident, determined and sureof his purposes . . Nixon saidthe ability to delegate is essential because the most precious asset of aleader is his own time. Early in the crisis Bush proved adept at resolvingpotential strategic conflicts between the more hawkish members of hisnational security team, such as Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitzwho advocated immediate military action against nationstates who hadsponsored terrorism such as especially Saddam Hussein's Iraq, and otherssuch as Secretary of State Colin Powell who urged the President to dealwith the Afghanistan/Taliban/Bin Laden situation first with the support ofa broad international coalition. Bush has made mistakes along the way. 2 1, A 26."Mr. Does Bush have sufficient sophistication concerninginternational affairs to hold his national security team and theinternational coalition together? 1 8-133.Beschloss, Michael. The events of September 11 suddenlypresented Bush with an unprecedented challenge. The failure to set goals is a sign of faltering leadership"(397). During the Republican presidential primaries,Senator John McCain, who came from a celebrated naval family, tapped intothe nation's tendency to identify with war heroes and captivated many withhis 'straight talk.' Bush appeared to overcome McCain largely because hisefforts were better financed. John Kennedy had benefitted from his father's wealth butwas a certifiable war hero in his own right. . New York: Harper & Row, 1978.Carlson, Margaret. A26). W., Jr. On September 11, Bush seemed to be somewhat hesitant in his responseand drew criticism for his decision to accept the advice of Cheney and theSecret Service by heading for air force bases in Louisiana and Nebraskainstead of returning directly to the White House from Florida. Some presidents with patricianbackgrounds, notably Theodore and Franklin Roosevelt, proved to beoutstanding leaders of the nation, but each of them, T.R. Bush (Bush) for leading the United States effectively during thecrisis created by the terrorist attacks on the World Trade Center in NewYork and the Pentagon in Washington and related threats. Much of what Bush has done is improvisational, areaction to events which perhaps should have been but were not adequatelyforeseen, by him and the rest of the national security and law enforcementestablishment. He appeared "overly bellicose,"said Beschloss when he uttered his 'dead or alive' comment about Bin Laden.It was imprudent and inflammatory for him to have referred to the Alliedcampaign against terrorism as a 'crusade,' which conjured up in the eyes ofMuslims an anti-Islam policy which was not Bush's intent. This impression was buttressed by Bush's tendency to uttermalapropisms such as "more and more of our imports come from overseas"(What 7). His popularity ratings in various polls were adequate --in the 5 -59 percent range-- but not out of the ordinary. . He [theleader] must perform" (326). Bush Pre-September 11 According to Greenstein, Professor Richard Neustadt, a leadingstudent of presidential leadership in the 196 s, popularized the view thatin the United States, "the presidency is the central institution of thepolitical system and that a strong, energetic president is necessary tomake the system work" (315). The answers to thesequestions are unknown. "No Middle Ground." New York Times, 14 Sept. In his speechat the National Cathedral on September 16, Bush, according to the New YorkTimes "struck the note of somber confidence that the nation was lookingfor" (President A 14). . 2 1, A 22."President Bush's First Win." New York Times, 17 Sept. on whether he can take command and actdecisively" (Awaiting A 24). As Nixon put it, the leader in a crisis "must bedecisive" (328). Bush's Most Important Speech." New York Times, 21 Sept. Behind the scenes Bush showed that he knows how to delegate authoritywhile at the same time making the key decisions. Kennedy The Endurance of Inspirational Leadership." Leadership in the Modern Presidency. Cambridge: Harvard U P, 1988. Bush in contrast had not beenparticularly successful in the oil business and had basically been savedfrom failure by the family fortune. The son of a former President George H.Bush, Bush gave the impression that in large measure his prominence was dueless to his own abilities and efforts and more to his inherited wealth andthe reputation of the Bush family. Since the end of the Cold War and withexception of the Gulf War, American presidents have not had to deal withlife threatening foreign policy crises. Bush appeared to capture the mood of a stricken nation, reassure itwhile at the same time exhorting it to remain steadfast in pursuit ofhigher purposes. Bush's clarion call for the nation to actforcefully against terrorism contrasted clearly with the more limited andoften ambivalent responses of the nation's leaders to prior terroristattacks, such as Ronald Reagan's humiliating retreat from Lebanon after theattack on the marine barracks in the early 198 s, his equivocal dealingswith Iranian Islamic fundamentalists in the context of the Iran ContraScandal and Bill Clinton's feckless responses to the Bin Ladenorganization's attacks on American embassies in Nairobi and Dar es Salaamin 1999. Apple said "the nation is rallying around its young,largely untried leader--as his rising approval ratings and theproliferation of flags across the country vividly demonstrates" (No A 1).Borger said on October 1 that public opinion polls showed that nearly 95percent of Americans supported his September 2 speech (34). Bush's Greatness as a Leader Bush has thus far exceeded just about everyone's expectations in hishandling of the current crisis. team and worried about his image, he was at his worst"(5 ). Leadership in the Modern Presidency. In July 2 1, the Economist said"the Bush presidency is stuck in the trenches" (1). All that one can safely say is that Bush hasresponded exceptionally well as a political leader in the early days of thecurrent crisis. "John F. As Nixon noted, "purpose is not enough. "From Core of Soul, Bush Inspires." Knight- Ridder/Tribune News Service, 24 Sept. He had overcome a serious drinkingproblem in the 198 s but this conduct bore resemblance to the irresponsiblebehavior of many rich scions who were afforded a second chance thatordinary persons lacked. Unlike Jimmy Carter whofell into the trap of micromanaging military affairs and politicalnegotiations during the Iranian hostage crisis, Bush has demonstrated thathe knows how to rely on key subordinates to implement policy. BUSH AS PRESIDENTIAL LEADER This research paper examines the capacity and skills of PresidentGeorge W. an assured appearance that should given citizens asense that their president has done much to master the complexities of thisnew global crisis" (A 22). "Bush Is An Idiot But Don't Tell the Europeans." New Statesman, 25 June 2 1, 2 ."What Did He Say?" New York Times Upfront, 19 March 2 1, 7.----------------------- 12 Bush's New Gravitas." New York Times, 12 Oct. . At the same time, Bush's appeal as the type of personwith whom one would like to socialize led many to conclude that he wasfairly ordinary. Burns said "all leadership isgoal-oriented. . "A President Finds His Voice." Time, 24 Sept. Leaders. Stephens of the leftwingNew Statesman said in June 2 1: "Bush is an idiot" and "Americans stilltend to be deeply embarrassed by Boy George's gauchiness and blatant lackof readiness for the presidency" (2 ). . However, as Nixon pointed out "the finalverdict of history [on a political leader] is not rendered quickly" (344).JFK, for example, at critical junctures, such as in his Inaugural Address,the Cuban Missile Crisis, and in calling for civil rights legislation,displayed outstanding leadership when "he . Bush's Response to the September 11 Attacks Nixon said that history suggests that for a national political leaderto be outstanding three conditions must be present, "a great man, a greatcountry, and a great issue" (2). A minoritypresident, who had failed to garner a majority of the popular vote, Bushhad no clear agenda to govern. Much the same could have been said concerning FDR'sexperimental solutions to the Depression or Lincoln's initial efforts topreserve the Union. News & World Report, 1 Oct. By these standards, Bush did not appear before September 11 topossess many of the qualities associated in the past with above averagepresidential leadership nor did the prevailing circumstances especiallyfavor the display of such talents. However,Kennedy also was capable of "empty public relations serving only to coverup substantive deficiencies" (125). Leadership. "Naive No More." U.S. According to Burns, in the highestform of political leadership, "transforming leadership," "leaders andfollowers raise one another to higher levels of motivation and morality"(2 ). Greenstein, ed. Nevertheless,Bush conveyed the impression that he was on top of his job, in command andcharting a course for the nation which was both responsive to the needs ofhis domestic audience but also a sensible path for the nation and the worldto follow in unprecedented circumstances. Does he have sufficient political skillsto keep partisan politics within acceptable limits? During the next few weeks, Bush has displayed strong leadershipcapacity and in the process confounding many of his critics. 2 1, K 674 ."Mr. The New YorkTimes complimented him for being "as strong and forthright as the nationcould have wished, while also maintaining a calm that must have reassuredthe world that the United States will be prudent as well as brave" (Mr. Bush effectively shepherded his #1 'signature' campaign issue, hisproposed tax cut, through Congress successfully, but by mid-2 1, many ofhis initiatives, such as his faith-based charitable approach to socialproblems, his energy and education bills were gaining little traction inCongress. have been great readers," somethingwhich mediocre Yale student Bush never has pretended to be (33 ).Expectations were, therefore, low when he entered office. 2 1, 5 .Greenstein, Fred I. 2 1, A 15.Borger, Gloria. Bush will face severe tests in the future as he implements his anti-terrorism policy. W., Jr. Most Presidents who have attainedhigh marks as leaders have had to deal with crises which were bothtraumatic and dangerous, Abraham Lincoln during the Civil War, WoodrowWilson during the First World War, FDR during the Great Depression and theearly days of World War II and JFK at the time of the Cuban Missile Crisis.Others who were confronted with serious national crises and who failed tomeasure up to their demands, such as James Madison during the War of 1812and Lyndon Johnson due to his mishandling of the Vietnam War, have beendealt with harshly by historians. After a somewhat shaky start, Bushresponded well to the crisis of September 11 and displayed many of theskills and characteristics of an effective President in dealing with thethreat of terrorism. While JFK is still very high in publicpopularity polls, historians have tended to downgrade his actualachievements over time. Bush's engaging personality emerged during the presidential campaigndebates where his personal warmth and self-deprecating humor contrastedfavorably with Vice President Albert Gore's seemingly arrogant and stiffpresentational style. His clumsy Bushisms together with his unabashed admissions thathe had little interest in the world of ideas and his inability to pronouncethe names of some foreign leaders reinforced his image as a man of limitedbrain power and international experience. New York: Warner Books, 1982.Stephens, Andrew. Mr. Bush remains an untestedfigure in the eyes of many Americans" (Demands A 16). Conclusion Bush is off to a promising beginning as an effective national leaderas evidenced by his conduct of the presidency since September 11. Bush's first eight months in office presented a mixed picture. "Awaiting the Aftershock." New York Times, 12 Sept. Works CitedApple, R. Fred I. (ed.). The New YorkTimes in its editorial of September 13 impatiently chided Bush: "he mustshow that he knows what he is doing . 2 1, A 1 & A 24.Apple, R. Marquez said that Bush "established a sense of purpose, so pure, soright that it left no room for moral relativism" (K 674 ). In his speech to a joint session of Congress onSeptember 2 , Bush seized the moral high ground declaring that the UnitedStates was engaged in a war to defend its freedoms and way of life againstterrorists and nations which harbor or support terrorists. . Nixon said"great leadership requires a great vision, one that inspires the leader andenables him to inspire the nation" (5). 2 1, A 14.Nixon, Richard M. All our great Presidents wereleaders of thought at times when certain historic ideas in the life of thenation had to be clarified" (Burns Preface). In taking the moral high ground, Bush evidenced a clear sense ofpurpose and took the moral high ground. He wasgenerally recognized to have selected an overall outstanding cabinetespecially in the national security arena. through hislifelong battle against ill-health in childhood and his exuberantpersonality, and FDR through his struggle to overcome the effects of polio,fell squarely within the American tradition of lifting up oneself by one'sown bootstraps. Apple said on September 12Bush "is likely to be judged . Greenstein agrees: "American presidentsstrongly influence public policy," but he adds, "the impact of thepresident is almost invariably a function of the personal leadershipqualities he brings to and displays in office, as well as the politicalcontext of the presidency" (1). 2 1, 2 .Burns, James MacGregor. Prior to theoccurrence of the events of September 11, 2 1, the extent of Bush'sPresidential leadership potential was very much in doubt owing in largepart to the public perception of him created during the recent presidentialelectoral campaign, the post-election dispute and Bush's performance duringhis first eight months in office. Cambridge: Harvard U P, 1988."In the Rough; George Bush's Troubles the State of the Bush Presidency." Economist, 14 July 2 1, 1.Marquez, Myricun. At the same time his seemingdeference to Vice President Richard Cheney suggested that he was not quiteready to assume the responsibilities of President. . Carlsen said "when Bushlistened to his p.r. 2 1, A 1 & A 4.Brauer, Carl M. . invoked moral arguments,appealed to people's idealism about serving big causes, and set exciting,ambitious goals for the nation and the world" (Brauer 125). Many of his publicpresentations appeared to be wooden, even boring. .predominantly a place of moral leadership. FDR said "the Presidency is . GEORGE W. However, it is much too soon to conclude that he willbe regarded by history as an outstanding presidential leader. He has proved to be politicallyadept both in fashioning a bipartisan consensus at home and a stableinternational coalition. In nipping this controversy in the bud infavor of a 'one war at a time' policy, Bush demonstrated a growingconfidence in his capacity to lead. In foreign affairs,Europeans seemed unimpressed and even antagonized by Bush's tendency towardunilateral moves such as his rejection of the Kyoto Treaty on globalwarming and his sponsorship of missile defense. If this paper is not what you are looking for, you can search again: Search for: or Click here to request an essay written just for you.

Many of our Papers can be Downloaded From This Site!

PLEASE READ THIS, IT IS IMPORTANT!

Office hours are Monday through Friday, from 9 am to 5 pm (PST). You may place orders for custom research over the phone during office hours. E-mail requests can be made to our graduate and undergraduate department any time, and will be reviewed during office hours. You may also contact customer service any time through e-mail, and we will review your message during business hours. A great many papers can be downloaded right from this site, but not all of them. If you would like to know if a particular paper is downloadable, just look in the description for: "Available for Internet Download: Y" or "Available for Internet Download: N" If you wish to purchase a paper which is NOT available for immediate download, you will need to make other shipping arrangements. Also, please be aware that these orders are processed Monday through Friday from 9 am to 5 pm (PST). If you place your order after 4:45pm on Friday, it will not be processed until the following Monday morning. We charge $8 per page for all of our pre-written reports, plus shipping (and tax for California residents). However, the highest cost of any ONE report is $136, or 17 pages. Please, take a moment. Make sure you have chosen the report you want or need BEFORE you complete your order. If you are not sure, allow us to help you. We do not offer refunds or exchanges, so it is important for you to let us answer your questions during office hours. Reports which are e-mailed or downloaded are in Microsoft Word format. We are making more reports available for e-mail delivery faster than we can update our listings. Please call to check on the status of particular reports. There are many other shipping options which are listed on the Checkout page.